Harold Halibut Metacritic Score Explained: 69 From Critics, 6.7 From Players
Harold Halibut's Metacritic score sits at 69 from critics and 6.7 from users. Here's what both sides praise, what they criticize, and who should play it.
Why the Harold Halibut Metacritic Split Matters
A 69 Metascore and a 6.7 user score rarely tell the same story, and in Harold Halibut's case the gap is the whole point. Slow Bros.' handcrafted stop-motion adventure, released April 16, 2024, is a game that critics respect more than they love and players love in patches while finding it a chore in others. If you're on the fence about spending $34.99 on a slow, dialogue-heavy narrative game, the Harold Halibut Metacritic breakdown below tells you exactly where the praise and the complaints land.
Harold Halibut Metacritic Scores at a Glance
The numbers below come directly from the game's Harold Halibut Metacritic listing, which aggregates critic reviews from all platforms.
| Metric | Score | Metacritic Label | Sample Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metascore (critics) | 69 | Mixed or Average | 26 critic reviews |
| User score | 6.7 | Mixed or Average | 126 user ratings |
Critic review breakdown: 38% positive (10 reviews), 62% mixed (16 reviews), 0% negative.
User rating breakdown: 47% positive (59 ratings), 36% mixed (45 ratings), 17% negative (22 ratings).
The most telling detail is the zero in the negative column for critics. Almost nobody reviewing Harold Halibut professionally dismissed it outright — but the majority landed in the middle, which is exactly what a 69 represents. Players were less forgiving: nearly one in five user ratings is negative.
What the Metascore of 69 Says About Critical Reception
Critics overwhelmingly agreed on one thing: Harold Halibut looks like nothing else. Reviews highlighted its striking stop-motion style, a world physically built by hand, and a premise about colonists stranded for generations aboard a submerged spaceship.
Several reviewers framed it as art first and game second, with one calling it a true work of art rather than a traditional game. Others praised its layered exploration of purpose — where a person fits into a universe far bigger than they can comprehend — and the richness of character growth despite a surprisingly linear path.
The criticism was consistent too:
- A meandering, risk-averse plot that doesn't fully justify its ambitions
- Minimal gameplay depth, with long dialogue-heavy stretches
- A bland protagonist and structural similarities to older oddities like The Neverhood that don't hold up on closer inspection
- Significant bugs at launch, according to at least one review
One reviewer summed up the tension neatly: an audiovisually enchanting adventure with likable characters that never quite convinces narratively and offers little mechanical depth.
Why the User Score Sits Lower at 6.7
Community reports skew harsher than the press, and the reasons are practical rather than philosophical. In user reviews, the recurring complaints are pacing and busywork.
Players describe quests that amount to fetch missions from point A to point B, long unnecessary walks between objectives, frequent loading screens, and waiting for assets to load. One detailed 2026 review argued the repetition is intentional — a way to mirror Harold's aimless life — but concluded that being boring is still the worst sin a game can commit, even when it makes the ending land harder.
Positive user reviews push back on the same points. Players who finished it describe a touching, funny, beautifully written experience with excellent voice acting and a memorable soundtrack, comparing the character designs to British stop-motion like Wallace and Gromit. Several said the ending made the slog worthwhile.
Not every complaint is about design. One 2026 user review reported crashes and said the experience felt like a 2009 release, which is a reminder that technical performance varies by player and platform.
The Art Style Is the One Thing Everyone Agrees On
Across critic and user reviews alike, the stop-motion presentation is the least contested element. The world and its inhabitants were literally crafted by people who cared about the story, and that craftsmanship shows.
One user noted the novelty faded after an hour or two but still stopped everyone in the house to watch. That's a fair summary of the consensus: the art earns immediate attention, and what keeps you playing — or doesn't — is the writing and the walking.
Who Should Play Harold Halibut?
Based on the combined Metacritic and community picture, this is a game for a specific temperament:
- Play it if you enjoy story-first adventures, stop-motion animation, office-style bureaucratic humor, and existential themes about home and purpose — and you don't mind slow pacing.
- Skip it if you need interactivity, challenge, or tight pacing. There is no way to lose, and the challenge is essentially absent.
- Buy it on sale if you're curious but uncommitted. One user's verdict was blunt: worth it at $10, not at full price.
If you're a fan of narrative adventure games and can tolerate repetition as a storytelling device, the 6.7 undersells it. If you bounced off similarly slow games before, the 69 is your warning.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Harold Halibut's Metacritic score?
The game holds a 69 Metascore, labeled "Mixed or Average," based on 26 critic reviews, and a 6.7 user score from 126 ratings. Both are categorized as Mixed or Average.
Is Harold Halibut reviewed negatively by critics?
No critic review in the Metacritic tally is negative. The split is 10 positive and 16 mixed, with the remainder of the 26 reviews falling into the mixed category overall.
What platforms is Harold Halibut available on?
Metacritic lists PC, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 5, and Nintendo Switch 2. The game was published by Slow Bros. and released on April 16, 2024.
Is Harold Halibut worth full price?
That depends on your tolerance for slow pacing. Community reports frequently mention long walks, repetitive fetch quests, and loading screens, while praising the art direction, voice acting, and ending. Many players recommend waiting for a discount.
The Bottom Line
Harold Halibut is the rare game where the Metacritic numbers are honest about its identity. A 69 and a 6.7 describe an ambitious, gorgeous, deliberately slow adventure that some players will find profound and others will find tedious — often within the same session. Check the full Harold Halibut review hub on Metacritic for individual critic and user write-ups before you decide.
Related Guides
Harold Halibut Review Reddit Roundup: Is the Handmade Adventure Worth It?
A Harold Halibut review Reddit roundup: what critics praise about the handmade art and story, where the pacing drags, and who should play it.
Harold Halibut Review: A Handmade Adventure With Heart and Pacing Issues
Our Harold Halibut review explores the stunning handmade world, Harold's emotional story, repetitive gameplay, and how the Switch 2 port performs.
Is Harold Halibut Worth It? A Candid Review of the Handmade Adventure
Wondering if Harold Halibut is worth it? We weigh its stunning handmade visuals, thin gameplay, slow pacing, and Switch 2 performance before you buy.